My group members and I walked into class Thursday, unsuspecting of what Professor Sanchez had in store for us. We trusted him to guide us
down the monotonous path formally known as “the history of cities and how they
have changed over time.” But, this mundane, commonly trodden, dirt path –
before our eyes – transformed into a lively park filled with adventure and
knowledge. This experience is what we make of it. And, being my group’s first
blog post, we intend to make the most of this situation. In todays post, we
hope to guide you - as the reader - through the roles of hierarchy, record
keeping, and walls in ancient cities (and we hope you learn something along the
way).
In class, our professor described hierarchy as “an innate
human creation.” He said it was created because of human’s desire for power,
and it also helps to organize people into distinct groups. Essentially, it
rewards people for their hard work (hopefully), and puts people in a specific
class that way, specialization can occur, increasing the overall efficiency of a
body/city. On the other hand, an article
from learninggeneralist.com claims the word hierarchy is hated by many modern
organizations because it tends to slow decision-making and undermine exceptional
people. I will attempt to cover up my bias in this post; however, I feel it is
clear what side most people will take on this issue. Historically, hierarchies
were employed because a king could not run a kingdom alone, thus he employed
advisors. These advisors, employed people to help them, and so on and so on
until we get down to the very bottom of the social pyramid – the slaves. “The hierarchy was in place to achieve a set of
organizational objectives and for leader to actually spend more time with their
people. So the purpose of hierarchy in the first place, wasn't really to add
process or slow down decision-making -- in fact it aided decision-making in a
big way. Nor was this to undermine exceptional people - in fact it was put in
place to get the best out of them and to ensure that there was someone
empowered to help them remove blockers and look at problems differently”
(http://www.learninggeneralist.com/2009/01/history-of-hierarchy.html).Yet, history has assured us that the goal hierarchies
were meant to fulfill was not achieved… sadly enough. Now… onto the role of
record keeping!
A need for record keeping has always
existed; whether it be orally, written down, etc.… In early times, record keeping was conducted mainly
through spoken word, passed down from generation to generation. This need for
record keeping was also described as “instinctual” by our professor: Humans
wants to learn from their mistakes and do not want to forget their
accomplishments. Records often did not have exact information such as dates and
places (http://undeception.com/ancient-vs-modern-history/). As time and technology progressed new forms of record keeping have been
created, such as writing down history and information on paper. This allowed
historians to become much more exact in their accounts of historical events
such as times, places, and people involved. Lastly, lets talk about the role of
walls in historic societies…
The
wall was one of the earliest forms of defense because nomads, wild animals, and
other cities surrounded historic urban societies- some with the goal of taking
over these establishments. Nomadic peoples knew that cities had food and water
and never hesitated to form raids in an attempt to obtain such supplies. Kings
often wanted to take over other cities for food, territory, and slaves, but
were prevented from doing so by one of the simplest, yet effective
structures—the wall. This important structure also acted as a tool for order
along with a Citadel. The wall, while normally meant for keeping unwanted
visitors out, was also used to keep uncooperative people in who retaliated
against the king. The Citadel also was used to represent a central authority.
With authority comes order.
The following website talks of the Great Wall of
China and how “its purpose was to protect China from outside aggression, but
also to preserve its culture from the customs of foreign barbarians” (http://www.globalmountainsummit.org/great-wall-of-china.html).
I would just like to start out by saying that I love the layout that you used for your site as well as your opening paragraph. However, I do believe that you failed to talk about the importance of the wall as a defend able structure. The wall was a total game changer because it gave the defender the advantage of height and added protection so that you didn't constantly have to have guards on duty. other than that, great job.
ReplyDeleteAmeen Mustafa
Group 24
Nice post. Try to include your links within the text of your post.
ReplyDelete